7) False Connection and the Loss of Local Impact
I can tell you the names of three activists I follow on Instagram who live 2,000 miles away.
I cannot tell you the names of the people who live on either side of me.
I know the policy positions of politicians in states I’ve never visited.
I don’t know the issues facing my own school board.
I feel deeply connected to movements happening across the country.
I feel completely disconnected from the people in my own neighborhood.
And I’m not alone.
We’ve been separated from that part of what used to work in the past—collective collaboration, proximate community—because of how technology has developed to make us feel like we’re so connected. But it’s a false connection.
We cannot make an impact at that level of connection.
And here’s what’s more dangerous: the more we connect with only a larger picture, the more we lose touch with what’s directly around us. And what’s directly around us is where change actually happens.
The Illusion of Digital Proximity
Social media has done something remarkable: it’s made us feel like we know people we’ve never met.
You follow someone’s journey. You watch their stories. You see their kids grow up, their struggles unfold, their victories celebrated. You feel invested. You feel connected.
They might feel like your bestie. But they don’t know your name.
And that’s the illusion. That’s the false connection.
You’re consuming their content. You’re emotionally engaged with their story. You might even be learning from them, growing because of them. But there’s no reciprocity. No mutual accountability. No shared context.
That’s not a relationship. That’s parasocial connection. And it cannot sustain the kind of civic engagement that actually changes systems.
Because systems change through relationships. Through people showing up for each other consistently, over time, in ways that build trust and shared power.
You can’t build that through a screen with someone you’ve never met.
Why Local Action Feels Too Small
I get it. I really do.
Local action feels small. It feels insignificant compared to the enormity of the problems we face.
Climate crisis. Democratic backsliding. Systemic racism. Economic inequality.
How is showing up to a school board meeting supposed to matter when democracy itself feels under threat?
How is getting to know your neighbors supposed to change anything when fascism is rising globally?
How is volunteering at a local shelter supposed to address the structural causes of homelessness?
It feels like rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic.
But here’s what we’re missing: the Titanic is made of neighborhoods. It’s made of local schools and city councils and community organizations and people who know each other’s names.
When those collapse, when those relationships fray, when local civic infrastructure crumbles—that’s when authoritarianism takes hold. Not because of some distant policy shift, but because people feel so isolated and powerless that they’re willing to hand over agency to anyone who promises to make them feel safe again [1].
The loss of local connection isn’t separate from the rise of larger threats. It’s the foundation of those threats.
Proximity and Power
Activist and lawyer Bryan Stevenson has spent his career fighting wrongful convictions and the death penalty. And one of his core teachings is this: “Proximity is powerful” [2].
Getting close to suffering changes you. Being in relationship with the people most affected by injustice makes it impossible to look away, impossible to accept easy answers, impossible to maintain comfortable distance.
But proximity requires presence. Physical, sustained, embodied presence.
You can’t be proximate through a screen. You can’t be proximate from 2,000 miles away. You can’t be proximate when you don’t know the names of the people suffering right next to you.
And here’s what happens when we lose proximity:
We start to perform solidarity instead of building it.
We post the right things. We share the right infographics. We change our profile pictures. We attend virtual rallies. We donate to distant causes.
All of that has value. I’m not dismissing it.
But it’s not a substitute for showing up in person, in your own community, for the people you can actually see.
The Deadly Myth: “They Don’t Make Them Like They Used To”
There’s a phrase I hear a lot: “They don’t make them like they used to.”
Usually it’s about gadgets, appliances, cars. Things that used to last and now break easily.
But it applies to community too.
There are some things that worked better in the past. The sense of community was larger. People knew their neighbors. They watched out for each other’s kids. They showed up when someone needed help.
But—and this is crucial—there was way too much that was not talked about.
It was discovered that the neighbor down the road was hurting the little kids in the neighborhood. So our world shrank. Then it was discovered that the pastor within the church group was doing similar, if not worse. So now, how does our world shrink when the few in charge have betrayed the system and made it fracture?
We responded to betrayal by withdrawing from proximity entirely.
Instead of fixing the systems that allowed abuse to happen—instead of building accountability alongside community—we retreated. We decided that distance equals safety. That not knowing people means they can’t hurt us.
But distance doesn’t equal safety. It equals isolation. And isolation makes us more vulnerable, not less.
Because when we don’t know our neighbors, when we’re not embedded in local community, when we have no proximate relationships:
We have no one to turn to in crisis
We have no collective power
We have no shared accountability
We’re alone with our screens, consuming content about other people’s lives
And loneliness is a political problem, not just a personal one.
What We Lose When We Only Look Up
Here’s what happens when we focus exclusively on national or global issues while ignoring what’s directly around us:
1. We lose the ability to influence anything
You have almost zero influence over national politics. Your vote matters, but your individual voice gets lost in millions. Your outrage on social media might feel cathartic, but it doesn’t move power.
You have significant influence at the local level. School boards, city councils, neighborhood associations—these are small enough that your voice actually matters. Your showing up changes outcomes.
But we’ve inverted the attention. We spend hours obsessing over things we can’t control while ignoring things we can.
2. We miss the early warning signs
National crises don’t appear out of nowhere. They show up first in local systems.
Schools losing funding. Libraries closing. Local journalism disappearing. Community centers shutting down. Small businesses struggling.
These aren’t just unfortunate side effects. They’re the infrastructure of democracy crumbling. And by the time it shows up on the national news, it’s already too late to stop it.
3. We lose our training ground
Civic engagement is a skill. You learn it by practicing. And you practice it locally.
You learn how to:
Speak at public meetings
Build coalitions across difference
Navigate bureaucracy
Organize your neighbors
Hold power accountable
You don’t learn those skills by posting online. You learn them by showing up, repeatedly, in your own community.
4. We abandon the people who can’t leave
If you can afford to mentally “check out” from your local community and focus on distant issues, you have privilege.
The people working three jobs can’t check out—they need the local school to be good because that’s where their kids go.
The people without transportation can’t check out—they need the local bus system to function.
The people without healthcare can’t check out—they need the local clinic to stay open.
When you disengage locally to focus globally, you’re abandoning the people with the least power to change their own circumstances.
The Beauty of Local Action
Here’s what local action offers that digital activism doesn’t:
Relationships that build power over time
When you show up at the same school board meeting month after month, you start to recognize the other people who show up. You learn who cares about what. You build trust. You coordinate. You become a force.
Immediate feedback loops
You advocate for a crosswalk. Six months later, there’s a crosswalk. You organize for better playground equipment. Next year, your kids are playing on it.
You can see that your actions matter. You can’t see that when you’re shouting into the void online.
Accountability that actually works
Your school board member lives in your town. Your city council representative shops at your grocery store. Your mayor’s kids go to school with your kids.
They can’t hide from you…and they’re not actually trying to. Proximity creates accountability that no amount of Twitter outrage can match.
Skills that transfer
The organizing skills you build locally—coalition building, strategic communication, navigating bureaucracy—transfer to larger fights.
But you can’t learn them in reverse. You can’t start by trying to change federal policy and then scale down. You have to build the muscles locally first.
Make an Impact With Your Sphere
So here’s my challenge to you:
Audit your civic engagement.
Last week, how much time did you spend:
Consuming news about national/global issues?
Posting about national/global issues?
Reading about activism happening in other places?
Now, how much time did you spend:
At a local government meeting?
Talking to your actual neighbors?
Volunteering in your own community?
Working on an issue that directly affects your immediate surroundings?
If the ratio is heavily tilted toward distant engagement, you’re not actually building power. You’re consuming content about other people building power.
And I’m not saying you should ignore national issues. I’m saying you need to balance your attention.
Because we start to see the people whose voices are not being represented when we pick our chin up and put the tiny screen down.
When we connect so that we feel the pulse around us. When we know our neighbors’ names. When we show up to local meetings. When we pay attention to what’s happening on our own block, in our own school, in our own town.
That’s where we find the people who need ours and their voices amplified. That’s where we build the relationships that create collective power.
So What?
This week, try this:
1. Introduce yourself to one neighbor you don’t know yet
Just one. “Hi, I’m [name]. I live at [address]. I realized we’ve never met.”
2. Find out when your local school board or city council meets
Go to one meeting. Just sit and watch. See who shows up. Learn what issues they’re discussing.
3. Ask one local business owner how they’re doing
Not “how’s business?” But “how are YOU doing? What’s hard right now?”
4. Spend one hour volunteering locally
Food bank. Community garden. Neighborhood cleanup. Literacy tutoring. Something you can touch.
5. Have one conversation with someone in your community about a local issue
Not national politics. Not global crisis. What’s happening HERE that needs attention?
These aren’t grand gestures. They’re not going to trend on social media.
But they’re how community gets rebuilt. One conversation at a time. One relationship at a time. One local action at a time.
And when we have enough people doing that—when we have people tending to their local systems while trusting others to tend to theirs—the larger system starts to shift.
We need the larger picture. We need to feel supported. We need to hear that in Detroit, someone thinks and feels the same as we do.
But if we just pump our fist in the air and say “see, someone thinks like me,” then we’re not doing anything in our surroundings. And we’ve lost the ability to see what we can do to change things within our direct surroundings, to impact the things that we can and should.
False connection feels good. It feels like solidarity. It feels like we’re doing something.
But real connection—proximate, local, embodied connection—is what actually builds power.
Put the screen down. Look around. Start there.
CITATIONS
Putnam, R. D. (2000). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Stevenson, B. (2014). Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption. New York: Spiegel & Grau.
Article 7
